How do you teach ’email’?

A student came to my office yesterday. “Hi Divya, I need to reply to an email about a job- do you think you could read it before I send it?” Of course, I said, and sat him down next to me. I frowned; where he was trying to be formal, I felt he came across as a bit aloof, where he tried to sound neutral, I read it as uninterested, where he tried to give a clear answer, to me he sounded slightly brusque. He burst out laughing “I like your teacher words – aloof, uninterested, brusque… you can just tell me it’s bad you know!” But that’s the thing, it wasn’t outright ‘bad’, it just didn’t hit the mark with me and maybe the recruiter he was writing to would have found it OK. I don’t really know.

Is there an internationally adaptable set of formulas for email? Who sets the standard for ‘good’ emails? How do we teach our students to handle communicating in a second / foreign language in a medium as sensitive, complex, hierarchical, demanding and powerful as email?

There is the trend of moving away from email, essentially because it can be a terrible time-suck that slows down work. A former student of mine tells me that his company  uses Slack , describing how thrilled he was that he hardly ever needs to write emails to get work done. A while back I read the interesting story of Claire Burge on BBC Capital.

““Email is a very selfish tool,” explained Burge, who now runs a Dublin-based consultancy called Get Organised. “People dump tasks into each other’s inboxes without thinking about whether they are being considerate.” The result is that “you become a slave to your inbox checking your email first thing in the morning until you go to bed.””

The keyword for me there is ‘dump’. While a lot gets done on email, there’s no denying that – a lot gets ‘dumped’ on email as well, some of which would probably fail the litmus test of saying something to a person’s face. We’ve all had the occasional ‘I’ve just survived a meeting that could have been an email’ moment but equally, many people have also experienced the other problem of ‘I’ve just had to survive an email that could have been a healthy dialogue’. The thing is, when email is used in unfiltered streams of consciousness to undermine, rant, criticise and assert position, work is sadly stripped of its meaning. And surely meaning is one of the most important motivators to work in the first place?

Rewind 16 years. My first of many odd teaching jobs in Paris was teaching English to the head of a small insurance outfit. He was of a certain generation where email hadn’t been the defining way in which the “desk-jobbers”, as he put it, spent time at work. There weren’t ‘extra points’ to be won by writing to colleagues about work late at night or on a Sunday morning. My job was to teach him email English because his company was staring to work internationally. In six weeks, I prepared vocabulary lists for him, different sets of stock phrases that he could use and classified them according to formal / semi formal / informal language, analysed some of the communication he had already sent out and received in English and made some recommendations. “It is like creating a new personality for me” he joked one day, “well it’s certainly a new voice”, I replied. At the end of this period, I considered my job successfully ‘done’. We didn’t stay in touch because his training was over and my odd-jobs were multiplying. Today, when I look at the level of care my colleagues and I invest in advising our graduates on how to email, and the time we spend drafting and re-drafting external communication, needless to say I blush at my vocabulary lists and stock phrases.

So my questions are- how do we teach people to communicate well on email? How to we define the etiquette around it? How will this etiquette, and the medium itself, evolve? Who decides which email structures are communicative and which ones are uncommunicative? How do you teach ’email’?

Featured image by A.D. Eker (artist), THE THUISMUSEUM. – uploaded by Keith Bates, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=13284839

5 thoughts on “How do you teach ’email’?

  1. Thought-provoking. I recall a certain ELT book by Thornbury that had a few sample emails of his. He showed that emails can become more informal as the two people correspond with each other. This may not always be the case, but it does usually happen in my experience.

    Also, I agree with you about emails that could have been meetings and meetings that could have been emails. But about Slack and other instant messaging programs: I remember the programs I used as an EPIK teacher in S Korea. The first computer I was given ground to a halt every time someone sent a school-wide message. This happened at least 5 times a day. I found it annoying.

    More to the point, what about things being dumped on instant message programs? I suppose the same criticisms about email can be applied to instant messaging.

    I’ll think more on how one teaches email.

    Like

    1. How interesting! See I have no direct experience of Slack, I didn’t realise it interrupted the workflow on the computer…but internal communication (only) five times a day sounds like a pretty good rhythm to me, excellent point about dumping on instant message, I think in both instances it’s the same problem of not thinking before clicking ‘send’…thank you for sharing your thought erm..Chewie?

      Liked by 1 person

      1. You’re right, now that I think of it. Five messages a day isn’t too bad. Maybe it was more. At any rate, yes, the problem lies with not thinking before hitting ‘send.’

        I don’t have any direct experience with Slack either, but my brother does. He works in IT and tells me most people in his company use Slack instead of email.

        And yes, Chewie’s a nickname from college that I held on to.

        Like

  2. Thank you for your post Diva,

    Do you perhaps believe that the reason why students are struggling with writing emails has more to do with their awareness of language register?

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s